Methods and architectures based on modular redundancy for fault. On the optimal design of triple modular redundancy logic. Triple modular redundancy layerzero power systems, inc. To be presented by melanie berg at government microcircuit applications and critical technology conference, orlando, fl, marc h 1417, 2016. Use voting to elect majority result and isolate atfault cpu. Design and implementation high reliability pwm modulator. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a common technique to protect memory elements for digital processing systems subject to radiation effects such as in space, highaltitude, or near nuclear sources. Triple modular redundancy using intel advanced vector. Hierarchical triplemodular redundancy htmr network. It significantly presents the formulation of transfer function, in its simplest form, of a triple modular redundancy faulttolerant sensor system. The use of triplemodular redundancy to improve computer. Trusted uses control to minimize system trips and provides high availability.
The numerical values of the failure rate, reliability and lifetime of the triple modular redundant system were obtained using weibull distribution. A microblaze tmr subsystem is of fault tolerant fail safe ftfs type, which means that it continues to. A form of redundancy in which the original computer unit is triplicated and each of the three independent units feeds into a majority voter, which outputs. Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion for reliable and trusted systems melanie berg1, kenneth label2. Full module redundancy is the required implementation of tmr in fpgas, because all the logic paths, not just the flip flops, are susceptible to seus. The approach is called functional triple modular redundancy ftmr. N vijaykrishnan department of computer science and engineering pennsylvania state university. Verification of triple modular redundancy insertion for. A faulttolerant alternative to lockstep triple modular. It is a form of n modular redundancy in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majority voting system to produce a single output.
In th is paper, a simple probabilistic model was proposed for analysis of fault masking performance of hierarchical tmr networks. Tripple modular redundancy article about tripple modular. For this reason, the wellknown 1 bit majority voter configuration. Hierarchical triple modular redundancy h tmr network for digital systems b. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a wellknown mitigation technique, which provides a full masking capability to single faults, although at a great cost in terms of area and power consumption. Modular redundancy reliability of computer systems and. E16 systems for high safety speed monitoring, all with.
Microblaze triple modular redundancy tmr subsystem v1. Pdf 1999 verilog hdl code for triple modular redundancy. Ceng 5334 chapter 4 n modular redundancy page 3 of 15. If any one of the three system fails, the other two systems can correct. Time triple modular redundancy, also known as ttmr, is a patented single event upset mitigation technique that detects and corrects errors in a computer or microprocessor. Differently from the traditional triple modular redundancy architectures, the. This is the venue of triple modular redundancy in oil, gas, energy, and chemicals. This paper presents an approach to verify the correct implementation of tmr for the memory elements of a given netlist i. Tmr is one of the most general and effective hardening techniques. Fault tolerance is a high performance system and they have ability of system to continue errorfree operation in presence of unexpected fault. The first part, section 2 presents n modular redundancy. Tmr is a wellknown technique for fault mitigation in which three redundant copies of the same logic perform the same task in parallel.
Faulttolerant digital systems development using triple modular. Fan module redundancy the dell modular server enclosure provides two cooling fan modules. Distributed tmr dtmr or global tmr gtmr xtmr but its not this easy tmr schemes are differentiated by how the triplication is performed and where the voters are placed. Tmr architecture uses three isolated, parallel control systems and extensive diagnos. Localized triple modular redundancy ltmr redundant data path. With just one failure, tmr continues to operate while continuously voting out the one failed module. Quadruple modular redundant technology for safety systems. The secondary unit typically does not monitor the system, but is there just as a. Triple modular redundancy verification via heuristic netlist. Modular redundancy tmr system, which contains three electronic redundancy units with weibull distribution.
To meet this, actel to automate these capabilities in their tools. This means that three full copies of the base design will be implemented to protect circuit functionality from seus, as well as sets. Voting, correcting codes, nmodular redundancy nmr, 42 concept, special logic, tmr with duplex. These are located in the middle of the rear of the chassis and provide redundant cooling to the chassis.
Mar 05, 2019 the three main models described in this paper are standby redundancy, n modular redundancy, and 1. Triple modular redundancy using fault tolerant technique. However, tmr suffers from a 200% area overhead problem 10,11. Transfer function of triple modular redundancy fault. Aikofahi hereby grant permission to the wallace memorial library of the rochester institute of technologyto reproduce mythesis in whole or in part. The secondary unit typically does not monitor the system, but is there just as a spare. Ttmr allows the use of very long instruction word style microprocessors in space or other applications where external sources, such as radiation, would cause an elevated rate of erro. Use of approximate triple modular redundancy for fault. Voter circuits, redundant voters, imperfect voters, and comparisons. Transcript music so, lets take a look at another example, namely a triple modular redundant system. Analysis of singleevent upset rates in triple modular redundancy devices. N vijaykrishnan department of computer science and engineering pennsylvania state university usa. Pdf design and analysis of a fault tolerant microprocessor. Verification of triple modular redundancy insertion for reliable and trusted systems melanie berg1, kenneth label2.
Jan 18, 2002 chapter 4 studies the reliability and availability gains obtained for n. In the proposed architecture, an onboard computer is designed based on triple modular redundancy tmr. Triple modular redundancy tmr is a suitable fault tolerant technique for srambased fpga. Also includes all the other standard or optional functions. Pdf on the optimal design of triple modular redundancy.
Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion for. In computing, triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triplemode redundancy, tmr is a. Such architecture is composed of one fault detection mechanism, several runtime recon. Each realized by a plugin monitor module encompassing the full channel function from sensor input and signal process, up to and including the safety trip relay outputs. In computing, triple modular redundancy, sometimes called triplemode redundancy, tmr is a faulttolerant form of n modular redundancy, in which three systems perform a process and that result is processed by a majorityvoting system to produce a single output. Reliability analysis of triple modular redundancy system.
Estimation the failure rate and reliability of the triple. A generalization of triple modular redundancy in which there are n identical units, where n is any odd number explanation of n modular redundancy. There are similar sounding terms like, tri or triple redundant, used in industry to describe other sts products but they simply do not yield the same, high level of reliability. In this paper, we develop the avtmr all voting triple modular redundancy system that is operated correctly in the case of a fault, and evaluate the. Imagine you have an embedded system which you want to perform very reliably.
The complete highreliability microblaze triple modular redundancy tmr solution for. In this paper, we concerned with the triple modular redundancy tmr for an onboard computer with aerospace application. Triple modular redundant configuration as it can be seen in figure 2, the redundancy of the onboard computer is in componentlevel and all. Find out information about tripple modular redundancy.
Contribute to thalesriscvtmr development by creating an account on github. Tmr defend the fpga circuit by creating three copies of a circuit. Hardware based double and triple modular re dundancy dmr and tmr 11 are the primary mechanisms for detection and recovery. Any reproduction will not be for commercial use or profit. Hierarchical application of triple modular redundancy tmr increases fault tolerance of digital integrated circuit ic. Reduced triple modular redundancy for tolerating seus in sram. Redundant system basic concepts national instruments.
Keyword fault masking, fault tolerant design, triplemodular redundancy tmr. Radial basis function rbf neural networks based on the. A faulttolerant alternative to lockstep triple modular redundancy by andrew lockett baldwin a thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of science in electrical and computer engineering thesis committee. Nmodular redundancy article about nmodular redundancy. In addition to the cell exclusion process or redundancy logic by manual means, there is a demand for automation in synthesis tools customized to your needs. However, one of the main challenges in achieving 100% robustness in designs protected by tmr running on programmable platforms is to prevent upsets in the. Standby redundancy, also known as backup redundancy is when you have an identical secondary unit to back up the primary unit. Fpga based multiple fault tolerant and recoverable. Music so, lets take a look at another example, namely a triple modular redundant system. Each fan module contains two fans that provide redundancy within the individual modules. Voter circuits, redundant voters, imperfect voters, and comparisons with parallel and standby schemes are included. The triple modular redundancy technique is used for detecting faults where, in case of inconsistency in one of the three processors caused by a fault, a new processor is recon. Transfer function of triple modular redundancy faulttolerant. In this paper, we develop the avtmr all voting triple modular redundancy system that is operated correctly in the case of a fault, and evaluate the avtmr system in the failure rate based on.
This unique qmr technology, based on a high level of selftesting and diagnostics, has proven that qmr is the best. However, one of the main challenges in achieving 100%. In this context, approximate tmr, which is the implementation. Performance improvements obtained by second order tnetwork were theoretically compared with first order tmr network. A vhdl approach has been developed for automatic tmr insertion and a demonstration design has been developed. Triple modular redundancy tmr uses three functionally equivalent units to provide redundant backup. Quadruple modular redundant technology for safety systems honeywells quadruple modular redundant qmr technology with award winning 2oo4d architecture sets the standard for how safety instrumented systems should be designed. When sharing io, the controllers from the mark vie and mark vies can read inputs from all io modules, but write outputs only to their own io modules.
A fault tolerant voter for approximate triple modular. One of the widely used and commonly known used fault tolerant modular redundancy technique is triple modular redundancy. Triple modular redundancy continuous time markov chains. Triple modular redundancy io modules on a common ionet to simplify operations and maintenance. Hierarchical triplemodular redundancy htmr network for. Redundancy operating systems and middleware group at hpi.
The use of redundancy can provide additional capabilities within a system. Triple modular redundancy verification via heuristic netlist analysis giovanni beltrame polytechnique montreal, montr. Pdf improving the fault tolerance of a computer system. Tripletriple redundant reliable onboard computer based on. Pdf improving the fault tolerance of a computer system with. Layerzero is the only provider of the benefits of tmr in power distribution systems. Redundancy is a technique to improve the reliability and availability of a system. Ttmr allows the use of very long instruction word style microprocessors in space or other applications where external sources, such as radiation, would cause an elevated rate of errors. This work compares two fault tolerance techniques, hamming code and triple modular redundancy tmr, that are largely used to mitigate single event upsets in integrated circuits, in terms of area. Reliability analysis of triple modular redundancy system with. The concept of redundancy contd time redundancy uses additional time to perform the functions of a system such that fault detection and often fault tolerance can be achieved. Error reduction rate per redundant module for the second. It is designed to provide maximum safety and system availability. Triple modular redundancy based on runtime reconfiguration.
Dependability modeling and optimization of triple modular. Trusted safety system triple modular redundant controller trusted system the trusted solution features a triple modular redundant tmr controller. The new system that oconee decided on the t ricon digital system, from the triconex unit of invensys process systems, of irvine, calif. If any one of the three systems fails, the other two systems can correct and mask the fault. Tmr guarantees an accurate output through a majority voter, even when a single module is faulty. Chapter 4 studies the reliability and availability gains obtained for n. Tmr sts are ideally suited when reliability simply cannot be compromised in single cord or dual cord power systems. The three main models described in this paper are standby redundancy, n modular redundancy, and 1. Triple modular redundancy, a proper noun, is a based on proven statistics and stringent mathematics.
For that reason, partial redundancy is often applied instead to alleviate these overheads. Pdf hierarchical triplemodular redundancy htmr network. Reliability analysis of triple modular redundancy system with spare i khalid a. Each fan module contains two fans that provide redundancy.
Verification of triple modular redundancy tmr insertion. Reduced triple modular redundancy for tolerating seus in. Triple modular redundancy is a proven topology in various life safety and mission critical systems across the industrial landscape. Regardless of how many clock stages may, or may not, lie between the inputs and outputs of the adder, the output is always a function of the inputs only. When the second failure occurs, the voter can no longer work without a majority. A fault tolerant voter for approximate triple modular redundancy. This document discusses the use of triple modular redundancy tmr for the protection of combinatorial and sequential logic in reprogrammable logic devices. Every monitor operates independently, but in constant co m. The design and evaluation of all voting triple modular.
742 679 260 647 1101 454 1614 1641 245 1593 1310 1075 1207 315 971 1632 1183 18 854 1254 245 835 449 293 758 1349 14 748 868 961 1099 477 343 565 981 235